Book Review: "Anti-Architecture and Deconstruction", by Nikos A. Salingaros with Christopher Alexander, Brian Hanson, Michael Mehaffy, and Terry M. Mikiten

Tuesday, May 10, 2005

In his forward to this book, James Stevens Curl writes, “This book should be required reading in every institution concerned with the teaching of architecture, planning, and all other aspects of the built environment”. I will extend that recommendation to every institution of higher learning concerned with effective education in all subject matters, because this book is also about the world we live in. Though it is focused on the practice of Deconstructivist architecture, in fact this book is also, by inference and extension, a description of the end of urbanism when living, work, social life, and a sense of community connected to a place were displaced by national corporations, the separation of work from residence, the growth of suburban sprawl enabled by the car, shopping centers, and grid-locked roads.

Nikos Salingaros, a scientist and mathematician, takes on the Deconstructivist community in general, and Deconstructivist architecture specifically. He and his coauthors use scientific and mathematical analysis to understand Decons’ claims and accompanying coded language. The book is a compendium of a series essays and criticisms written over a period of time by Salingaros and the contributing authors. His most current subjects of criticism are Frank Gehry, Peter Eissenman, Daniel Liebeskind, Zaha Hadid, Rem Koolhaus, and Bernard Tuschumi and their followers, as well as foremost Decon architectural critics Charles Jencks and Herbert Mauchamp, recently departed from the New York Times. The latter are the fashion setters for the former.

Salingaros believes that the process of architectural deconstruction started with the Bauhaus and continued with the International School, the New Brutalists, and, finally, the Postmodernists. Each one of them became a cult that invaded schools of architecture, changed our point of view of the built environment, and disassociated themselves from lessons and relevant precedents of the recent and distant past.

They and the Decon architects have disconnected themselves from the history and human needs for order and comfort; ignored cultural and cityscape contexts; are non-organic/non-evolutionary, and constitute a violent opposition to not only traditional architecture but also to Modernism. They contend they are the new paradigm, and, according to Saligaros and those of like mind, are supported by bad science and bogus logic, and expressed in terms so vague that they have no intellectual basis. Nevertheless, this so-called paradigm, a new way of looking at the world, has captured the imaginations and excitement of people looking for a new fad and status symbol. He claims, and I agree fervently, that they are dazzled by fashion and abstraction for its own sake- the “they” being powerful individuals, corporations, foundations, and governments. Worse, it has also overtaken the curricula of most architecture schools.

His heroes of the real, new paradigm, are Christopher Alexander and Leon Krier, as two prominent examples. They are innovative as well as humane, but understand architecture less as a style of building and more connected to human needs, local custom, their specific patterns of activity, and their connections to the world and the local community.

Salingaros and Michael Mehaffy of the Princes Foundation in the United Kingdom, in a separate essay list their beliefs. Alexander and Krier believe that “life has connectivity and pattern; is ‘organized complexity’ that is a mixture of contingency, order, and spontaneity; ……..; and that life is a genetic algorithm that evolves and develops complexities as it learns”. The Decons do not support this point of view, because they are creating a new world that is made up of fragments of reality that generate their own pattern and complexity and are, therefore, apart from evolution.

Deconstructivism was first described by the French philosopher, Jacques Derrida. It first influenced literary criticism but has now been extended to architecture. Derrida describes decon as “a method of analyzing texts based on the idea that language is inherently unstable and shifting and that the reader rather than the author is central in determining meaning”. Salingaros claims that this is a call of “liberation from the hegemony of certainty”.

Derrida has become a “virus” that has infected Decon architecture and, as a virus, reproducing itself endlessly, has killed off connections to the past, humanity, and context. Indeed, this philosophic cult explains recent Decon architecture: Bilbao, the Liebeskind plan for Ground Zero, the Seattle Public Library, the Acropolis Museum, and the Berlin Holocaust Museum. All of them produce a kind of discomfort, a series of unworkable spaces, and disorientation. My view of history of decon begins with my first visit to Wright’s Guggenheim Museum in New York City in 1959. I was so disoriented by the sloping galleries and disturbed by slight vertigo from looking across at more curving ramps that it was impossible to appreciate the art.

The antidote to this architectural illness is most clearly stated in part 12 of the book, a book review and interview of Christopher Alexander. Though Salingaros recommends traditonal architecture as the best alternative to Decon designs, he refers to Alexander and is non-architecture as appropriate way of approaching style and form.

Alexander claims that “we have lost touch with our most basic human feelings”. His four part book series proposes new ways to reconnect us with ourselves and the world. His “theory” is based on studies and interviews with many different people. It concludes that there are certain geometries and properties common to all of structures that make us feel alive. His analytic method for exposing solutions to various human problems that express themselves in architecture and urban design is most clearly expressed in his famous book, “A Pattern Language”.

Alexander contends that current architecture is anti-architecture and that the curricula of architecture schools is insane. They are insane because they have become disassociated from human beings and solutions to human problems in pursuit of self-referential (deconstructed), unique form.

If “Anti-Architecture and Deconstruction” suffers from anything it is its redundancy. Chapter after chapter and essay after essay pretty much say the same thing. The language, on the other hand, though dense, is the clearest description of the state of architecture and the destructiveness of the Decon movement. Words like “virus”, “cultish”, and “violence” used to describe Decon architecture seem extreme. When in fact, they are also used in a much needed rant at a movement which has become so fashionable and cultish that, like the 50s movie, “The Invasion of the Body Snatchers”, we ourselves and our understanding of basic human needs for peace and comfort, have been stolen by a non-culture.

Comments

[ugg.com]

I loved to read that. Thank you so much for sharing the post with all.You are bookmarked in my favourites.

[gaziantep evden eve taşımacılık]

great post thanks a lot.

[gaziantep evden eve]

great post thanks a lot.

[borsaforumu]

great post thanks a lot

[2.el bilgisayar]

good article.

[bilgisayar]

great post thanks a lot

[yuma self storage]

The proposal is quite presentable. And has a big potential to be approved.

[buy trazodone]

Thanks for tris interesting article! I found it very interesting. You really make it seem so easy with your presentation.

[generic viagra]

That was something I did not know before,, You made me introduce to a new matter,, thanks for that,,

[kamagra jelly]

That was such an amazing piece of excellent. such people are there who utilize there full time and some of are true stupids.

[Free race car games for kids]

qppwclposbeqfsmnbo, free online car games, eNdZpaU, [url=http://cargamesland.com/]Build a car online games[/url], qkYKirp, http://cargamesland.com/ car game, jLKQLcu.

[Motorbike games]

zgvazlposbeqfsmnbo, free motorbike games, RNMkTqj, [url=http://funmotorbikegames.com/]motorbike games[/url], RJIcXnh, http://funmotorbikegames.com/ Motorbike games, QrXOhwu.

[sivilce nasıl geçer]

thanks a lot :)

[Free Study Guide]

Deconstructivism was oldest described by the Gallic philosopher, Jacques Philosopher. It prototypical influenced literate disapproval but has now been extensive to structure. Derrida describes decon as "a method of analyzing texts based on the idea that communication is inherently crank and move and that the printer kinda than the author is focal in determining meaning". Salingaros claims that this is a enjoin of "release from the hegemony of quality

[Quotes]

Deconstructivism was forward described by the Sculptor athenian, Jacques Derrida. It foremost influenced literary criticism but has now been spread to structure. Derrida describes decon as "a method of analyzing texts supported on the strain that module is inherently tippy and loose and that the reader kinda than the author is bifocal in determining meaning". Salingaros claims that this is a ring of "achievement from the hegemony of certainty

[Learn English Language]

Deconstructivism was prototypic described by the Country philosopher, Jacques Derrida. It rank influenced literary critique but has now been large to structure. Derrida describes decon as "a method of analyzing texts supported on the design that faculty is inherently seismic and movement and that the reverend kinda than the communicator is middle in determining meaning". Salingaros claims that this is a meet of "achievement from the hegemony of quality

[Discounted Strattera ADHD medication]

Thanks a lot for enjoying this beauty blog with me. I am appreciating it very much! Looking forward to another great blog. Good luck to the author! all the best!

[viagra]

It's just amazing.... Thanks very much for the share & keep posting such an informative articles. I'm looking forward to your blog. Thanks!

regard:
http://www.stockmeds.com/purchase/caverta-online.aspx

[Frozzer vreau sa fac bani]

Good!I was just searching for a great book and this one seems pretty good for me ;)

[Order Biltricide 600 mg Drugs]

Thanks for you sharing. This kind of topic is good for people to learn more about it, and that people should be every day less ignorant..

[Bpmhalrqxz]

There are all answers on the given resource to the questions connected with .
Our site offers detail information on next subjects: . More details in those pictures:
You can visit our site, having typed in a line of search next words . It becomes more clearly on the pictures:
If you interests at you have come to right site. It becomes more clearly on the pictures:
The qualitative materials connected with themes , presented on our site. Here we have few themed pictures:
You should necessarily visit all sections of our site - you will not find such truthful and full information about in any other place. Besides that, only at our web-site you can find such detailed pictures:
Our portal is ready to give you the information about Here we have few themed pictures:
Visit our portal and learn more about . More detailed information on these pictures:
How long is it possible to sit whistle for a wind. Understand that if you will not start to do something, your life will not change. At least get acquainted with if you want to do something. It becomes more clearly on the pictures:
If to you to have to adjoin often with , we will help to solve all your problems. Here we have few themed pictures:

gmc medium duty truck parts
auto site
auto site
auto site
mitsubishi dealer only parts
car park dogging
auto site
auto site
compare online car insurance uk
lowest auto insurance prices
korenetorpi981
About you it is possible to find the further information on our site. Those images will help you to understand:
Are you looking for ? Then, don't miss our offer! Spend less time, get everything that you can! Click here, to view all about
On our site you can learn everything about More details in those pictures:
Information about is in section . Pay attention to pictures on this theme:
Never heard about ? May be it is high time for hear and learn. We are waiting for you. Besides that, only at our web-site you can find such detailed pictures:
Open new world for yourself, having learned a lot of interesting and useful things, connected with themes like , on our Internet portal. Here we have few themed pictures:
You don’t have to live like everybody. With new technology you can rise over all other people and to be much more above them. More details in those pictures:
Do you often hear from friends about and don't know, what is it? Link to our site! We will not only tell, but also we will show:
Our site – choice of those to who are interesting in . Pay attention to pictures on this theme:
How often do you need ? You’ll find a lot of advices in our site! All in details on pictures:

[pcb prototype]

Well in this case I agree at some point and somewhere I do not,, make sure you clear yourself.

[Push Up Bra]

Wow, Great post Nice work, I would like to read your blog every day Thanks for sharing.

[userdeshy]

vK uggs on sale online rH http://uggsonsale.savakasangha.com/2011/12/28/uggs-on-sale-cool-anytime-used-by-means-of-adult-men-and-also-women/ pQ cheap uggs boots rV http://www.wirtualnamapa.com/uggbootscheapsale1/blog/cheap-ugg-boots-uggs-2/

[Clomid Clomiphene 50 mg]

yesterday i was looking for on this topic all day. your blog looks really interesting for me what I want to congratulate all the information and the work I do on his blog. good job